logo

52 pages 1 hour read

Before We Were Yours

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2017

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 5-8Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 5 Summary

In the company of her father’s assistant’s intern, Avery returns to the nursing home where the Senator had his recent photo op. A bracelet belonging to Avery was found in the possession of May, the old woman who grabbed her hand and called her Fern. Avery goes to retrieve the bracelet because it contains sentimental value for her. It was a gift from her grandmother, Grandma Judy, who is also now in the nursing home. It pains Avery to connect the dots between this lonesome woman, May, and any sadness Grandma Judy might be feeling, emotions that could be buried beneath her worsening dementia. Avery feels that she needs to know more about this woman, May. She reflects inwardly: “She’s a person, like Grandma Judy” (45). Avery wants to show kindness towards May because she worries that she may have gotten her in trouble over the bracelet that May somehow managed to slip off Avery’s arm. Avery worries that she “made a bad situation worse” (45).

After picking up the bracelet from the nursing home director, Avery asks a few questions about May, namely if she has any family nearby. She is told simply that “it’s complicated” (45), and it seems to Avery that May is utterly alone. She decides to pay May a visit and creeps quietly into May’s room. When she realizes May isn’t there, Avery begins to poke around a bit. An old photograph catches her eye, one of a man in a “battered fedora” with “slim shoulders cocked back” in a way that “speaks of confidence, defiance almost” (46). Avery takes a photo of the photo with her phone and at that point May walks in. May scrutinizes Avery all over again and tells Avery that she thinks she knows her grandmother. She asks Avery if her grandmother lives nearby and if she could see her. Avery begins to think that May “isn’t as addled as she’s been pretending to be” (47).

Back home again, Avery asks her mother if there could be some connection between Grandma Judy and this woman, May. Her mother waves away the idea, saying: “She probably just knows of us, Avery. Many people do” (50). Avery is irritated by her mother’s snobbish answer and also feels like she’s not getting the full story.

Chapter 6 Summary

Rill waits on the shantyboat to hear word of her mother and the babies struggling to be born. Meanwhile, she tries her best to care for her siblings. When Zede, the doctor, arrives at her door, he does not “chase round the bush with his words” but instead tells her simply and directly: “Queenie’s babies didn’t make it” (53). It was not the fault of Briny or the midwife, Zede tells Rill. Nothing could’ve been done. Zede explains that “the babies just wasn’t meant for this world, that’s all” (53). Queenie is still incoherent on pain meds at the hospital, Zede tells Rill. No one has even told her about the loss of the babies. Rill imagines the suffering her mother will feel, thinking: “I know Queenie. She won’t be alright. Nothing makes her happier than a brand-new, sweet baby to cuddle” (54).

Because Briny and Queenie are not yet ready to come home from the hospital, Zede brings someone to watch over the kids, a teenager named Silas. Rills discover that Silas “has seen a bit himself,” once he eats some breakfast with them and begins to “tell tales of riding the rails and thumbing his way across five states” (56). When the younger siblings ask why he left home, Silas explains that his stepfather drank and beat him. Silas tells the kids to “[b]e glad if you got a nice mama and daddy. […] Don’t ever get it in your head to leave them” (57). Rill and the others certainly don’t intend to.

Silas and Rill begin playing house a bit, Rill fussing in the kitchen while Silas wanders cautiously outside to fish. The two engage in some flirtation but are abruptly interrupted by the sound of a stranger approaching the shantyboat. It’s a police officer at the door, and he pushes his way through. Silas tries to tell the officer that he is there alone while the younger kids jump off the boat and into the river. The officer is not alone, however, and the police with him soon round up all the other siblings. Camellia puts up the biggest fight, hiding in the outhouse and getting covered in waste. One officer tries to grab Rill, licking his lips and hissing: “Ain’t you a pretty little river rat?” (63). The children are all loaded onto a motorboat and taken to Memphis where a car is waiting for them. A woman, Miss Tann, looks them over and smiles appreciatively at the “lovely bunch of foundlings […] Five precious blonds with curls. How perfect” (67). Rill tries to tell the woman her youngest brother’s name but is scolded: “Restrain yourself from answering questions unless you are asked” (68).

Chapter 7 Summary

Avery goes to visit her grandmother in the stately, exclusive facility where Grandma Judy now resides and where “[n]ot just anyone is allowed to enter” (69). Unlike the nursing home where her Senator father had his PR visit, this home sports “a sprawling front lawn” and “it’s easy to picture Scarlett O’Hara fanning herself beneath the moss-draped live oaks” (69). Grandma Judy’s new home is the best place that money and fame can buy.

Avery is glad to see that her grandmother is alert and upbeat when she arrives at her tidy, cheerful little room in the “Memory Care Unit” (70). Grandmother and granddaughter make pleasant chit chat. Then, after asking Grandma Judy if she knows a woman called May Crandall, Avery shows Grandma Judy the photo she took with her phone. To Avery’s surprise, “[m]oisture wells up in her eyes” (73). Grandma Judy touches the image, whispering “Queenie” (73). She then tells Avery, “They can never know about Arcadia” (73). Avery is puzzled, all the more so when Grandma Judy tells her: “Be careful, Rill” (74). Avery isn’t sure what this means or if Rill is a name, but the spell is broken when an orderly come in, delivering coffee. Grandma Judy returns abruptly to the present day.

Chapter 8 Summary

Rill and her siblings are shuffled into a “big white house […] that reminds [Rill] of Sleeping Beauty’s castle” (76). There are children out in the yard, groups of them, yet they scatter when Miss Tann appears. Camellia demands to know when they are going to the hospital to see Briny and Queenie, and Miss Tann promises to take them: “If you’re good. Am I understood?” (77). However, Camellia is disobedient when told to march inside and to sit silently in the hallway, waiting to be bathed and cleansed of “the river and […] vermin” (77). Another woman, Miss Murphy, appears and pronounces it a very productive day. Rill notices that Miss Murphy stinks of whiskey when she comes close to the children to expect them. Both of the woman fuss over the children, especially their blond ringlets. Delighted, Miss Murphy says aloud, “They’re darling, aren’t they? And young. They might not stay long. We’ve a viewing party planned next month. I’ll expect them to be ready” (83).

Rill doesn’t know what is going on, but she knows that it’s bad. She channels her thoughts towards the bird she notices flittering around the window, willing the bird to “[f]ly away. Go on home” (83), as she herself wishes she could do. Rill is asked to explain her name, and she tells the women that her father gave it to her, that he named her after the river and its pretty song. The woman decides this won’t do, that she needs “a real name for a real girl” (81) and tell her that she is now “May.” All the siblings are then told to strip naked and get ready to be bathed.

Chapters 5-8 Analysis

Memory and discovery dominate this section of the novel. Avery is sure that there is more to the story of May Crandall then anyone is letting on. She can’t put her finger on it, but she feels a kinship with this woman whom she has been told has no kin and based on class should have no connection to her. Yet the vague emotional pull endures.

The photo in May’s room in the nursing home works a strange magic on both Avery and May. Avery becomes lost in her imagination. She wants to slip beneath the sepia of the old images and find out more about these people standing on a boat, wearing expressions of resilience and defiance. They are strangers to her yet also strangely familiar. For May’s part, the photo seems to make her snap to. She is no longer haunted and distant in conversation. After they look at the photo together, May is able to make clear requests of Avery. She wants to know who her grandmother is, where she lives, and if she can see her. Avery cannot offer May any info or coordinate a visit, but Avery does decide that it’s time for her to visit Grandma Judy.

During this visit, the photo works even more profound magic. Avery is never sure what her grandmother will know or not know now that she is battling dementia. When Avery produces the photograph, Grandma Judy seems to travel to another time and place, leaving Avery behind entirely. The words “Arcadia” and “Rill” are mysterious and bespeak another life, one that Avery can only guess at. There is no way for Avery to imagine the scene Rill details in her narration, of the police raiding their “shantyboat,” rounding up the children and turning them over to a woman waiting in a car, a Miss Tann. There’s nothing in Avery’s life that would help her envision the home the children were taken to, full of other “foundlings” (67) stolen from riverbank encampments, tidied up and given new names and identities.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
Unlock IconUnlock all 52 pages of this Study Guide

Plus, gain access to 8,800+ more expert-written Study Guides.

Including features:

+ Mobile App
+ Printable PDF
+ Literary AI Tools