Tecumseh and the Quest for Indian Leadership

In Chapter 3, Edmunds outlines the traditional political structure of the Shawnee. How does Tecumseh’s model of leadership depart from this? What leads Tecumseh to adopt his new conception of leadership?

What is the role of so-called “British Indian agents,” like Matthew Elliott, in British-Native relations? How does this role affect Tecumseh and his movement?

What are the most important features of Tenskwatawa’s religious revival as described in Chapter 4? Why is the Prophet so effective in gaining disciples?

Tecumseh is consistently opposed by older leaders, like Black Hoof and Little Turtle, who urge accommodation and adaptation to the European lifestyle as the best way forward for Native Americans. How would Tecumseh respond to this argument?

Why does Governor Harrison decide to attack Prophetstown in the Battle of Tippecanoe? Are there any factors in his decision that could have been avoided or mitigated by either Tecumseh or Tenskwatawa?

Tecumseh blames Tenskwatawa for their defeat at the Battle of Tippecanoe. Why? Does Tecumseh reach a fair conclusion regarding the event? What does his conclusion say about the relationship between the two brothers?

Tecumseh is far more successful in his alliance with General Isaac Brock than with Colonel Henry Procter. Why? Use at least two examples from the text in your answer.

Why does Edmunds declare that “the Indian movement had ended” with Tecumseh’s death? What qualities does Tecumseh have that are difficult for other leaders to replicate?